Reviews and previews for the film version of New Moon, the second book in the famed Twilight series promised that this movie, compared to the first Twilight film, would have a bigger budget; better acting; a more experienced director; and a much, much more muscular Taylor Lautner (Jacob). New Moon definitely delivers on all counts. This movie is a well done, entertaining movie. It stays true to the events of the book (for the most part) and adeptly builds the relationship between Jacob and Bella (played by Kristen Stewart). The scenes in Italy are particularly breathtaking and perfectly match Meyer's descriptions. Also, the special effects are noticeably improved from the first film. Even Edward's sunshine sparkle is almost believable.With all of these positive qualities and technical improvements, it is only logical to think that New Moon is better than the original, low-budget Twilight film. In many ways, it probably is, but as a movie adaptation of the book, the movie Twilight is better. When it comes down to it, New Moon is too good. It is too professional, well-executed, and convincing. I know, it seems like a ridiculous complaint, like a teacher giving a bad grade on a paper because it is too well-written. Although New Moon succeeds in many ways, it fails to capture the essence of the Twilight books. For me, one reason the books are so great is that they are as fun to laugh at as they are supremely addicting. Stephenie Meyer makes up for her lack of actual writing talent in her ability to craft a fast-paced, exciting story. The first Twilight movie, with its inexperienced director and low quality special effects, captures this feature exceptionally well. While Twilight captivates audiences and absorbs viewers into the story, it is also funny—from Edward’s blinding sparkles to his ridiculous apple-catch. New Moon lacks most of this quirkiness (though it does have its moments, such as the scene where Jacob whips off his shirt to use as a bandage for Bella’s head wound and shows off his eight pack…classic) and in a way, this absence detracted from my enjoyment of the movie.
However, some omission of comedic element is understandable. New Moon has to deal with a few more serious issues than Twilight did, such as Bella’s debilitating depression after Edward leaves her and the death of a supporting character. The film handles these serious subjects convincingly and Kristen Stewart delivers an impressive performance.
All in all, I did like New Moon, considering my main complaint with the movie is that it's too good. And I definitely will be buying a ticket to go see Eclipse in 2010.
--Michelle
Posts
